Jamestown: New Hope or Death Trap?

When the Susan Constant, Godspeed, and Discovery crept up the Chesapeake and landed along the James River in 1607, the 105 passengers and 39 crew members were all male: Soldiers and men out to make a name or fortune for themselves. They had not traversed the Atlantic and spent four and a half months in travel in order to do anything mundane like farming. Many were from the upper class, second and third sons of the wealthy. Blacksmiths, carpenters, and other skilled laborers were present, as well.  Every member of the expedition was an employee of the Virginia Company who expected them to make a profit for the company. They hoped to discover gold and silver or a route to the East Indies. What they found, instead, were trees, furs, and approximately 14,000 Powhatan and Algonkian-speaking Indians.

Life was rough. They didn’t know how to grow food in this new world, and this combined with a brackish water supply, diseases they’d never been exposed to, and occasional hostilities between them and the Powhatans led to a death rate of over 50%. Forget riches, finding enough food and good water for survival became the main goal. By the end of the first winter, only 38 of the 105 colonists were still alive. The winter of 1609, known as the “Starving Time,” was worse. Archeological evidence suggests that some resorted to cannibalism. The colony would likely have not survived at all without the help of Pocahontas.

But this did not stop more English from making the miserable journey across the North Atlantic, trapped in the holds of ships with spoiled food, rats, and other pestilences. Why? Why did the later colonists keep coming even after they’d heard the horror stories and knew the risks?

These adventurers (anyone is an adventurer, in my opinion, if they’re willing to sail across the ocean into the unknown, even if they be farmers, glassmakers, or even seamstresses) were willing to risk their lives for freedom and hope. England was in the middle of a population explosion and still in the grip of a medieval caste system that provided little opportunity for rising above the station one was born into. And even if one had the funds, land was scarce.

The New World abounded in natural resources: forests as far as the eye could see, plentiful fish and animals, and abundant land beyond measure. America offered the opportunity to dream and to believe that those dreams might come true if one were willing to work hard enough.  America offered the opportunity and “freedom to become somebody.” And the men and eventually women who came were willing to risk everything, including their very lives for that hope.

(Next week, I’ll discuss the “women problem.” All men and no women does not a lasting colony make. The following week, I’ll explore the Powhatans. The land wasn’t empty after all.)

 

Sources:

Jamestown Settlement. https://jyfmuseums.org/jamestown-settlement/

McDermott, Annette. “What Was Life Like in Jamestown.” History.com. 25 July 2018. https://www.history.com/news/jamestown-colony-daily-life

 

 

Jamestown Settlment
By Pi3.124 - Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0

7 thoughts on “Jamestown: New Hope or Death Trap?”

  1. Loved this, Sherry! I lived in VA for a year and studied our American roots quite a bit. Funny how the Lord uses our discomfort to spur us on to great things for Him!! By why anyone would want to put themselves in a small boat to cross turbulent oceans still amazes me!! Thank God these men and women did!!!

    Enjoyed this post very much! Thank you! 🙂

    1. Thank you! I’m glad you enjoyed it. Yes, they were definitely braver than me. YOu make an excellent point about how God can bring good out of our hardships and discomforts. He can create art where we see mud.

  2. What a fascinating picture of their fort. It made me lose all hope they might survive.

    I’m eager to read your next Jamestown discussions!

    1. Yes, the fort doesn’t look like much considering it was a foothold in the New World. One of the reasons they placed it on the James River, instead of at the mouth of the Chesapeake Bay, was that they were trying to hide from the Spanish. Not only did they have to worry about the Powhatans, but they also had the Spanish to fear. I’m glad you enjoyed the post:)

  3. Great article, Sherry. I did not realize many of the colonists were among the wealthy. I guess I always thought of them as farmers. Goes to show how little I know about our American history. I am thankful for people like you who bring it to light for us in such an interesting manner.

    1. The trouble in Jamestown was that too many of them were from the upper class and from skills like goldsmithing, etc. What the colony needed was farmers, men who knew how to work hard and grow food. Eventually, the company sent farmers over, but it took a few years.

Comments are closed.