Voices of the Past
Historical Romance Author

Indian Princess and the Soldier: Love Story or Myth
Friday, July 15, 2022 by Sherry Shindelar
As a historical romance author, I love the traditional romantic story of Pocahontas and John Smith falling in love. However, much of the research paints a different picture:
Pocahontas was the “most deare and wel-beloved” daughter of the most powerful Native American chief in Virginia. Her father Powhatan, aka as Wahunsenacawh, was the chief political leader for the Algonquians, around 15,000 people spread out in more than thirty villages stretching from the James River to the Potomac.
Her name was originally Matoaka, meaning flower between two rivers, but later changed to Pocahontas, meaning playful or wanton child.
Only 11 or 12 years old at the time she met John Smith, Pocahontas became his dear friend and a peace liaison between her people and the English. She helped save the lives of John Smith and the other early colonists at Jamestown. However, whether or not Smith’s live was actually in danger upon their famous first meeting is up for debate.
Smith was captured by some Powhatan warriors and shown off at several villages before being taken to the capital. There, he was presented to Powhatan. Suddenly, he was grabbed, and his head was forced down upon a stone. Several warriors stood over him with clubs, ready to strike, when Pocahontas threw her arms around him and placed her head over his. She then drew him up, and Powhatan welcomed him as a son, giving him a parcel of land for the English to settle on instead of the putrid water area of Jamestown.
Smith believed that the girl had saved his life. Further, research into Indian customs suggests that the traumatic event Smith experienced was an adoption ceremony.
Either way, there was a special bond between Smith and Pocahontas, and she cherished that relationship. As an 11 or 12 year old, she could have been infatuated with him or even in love. Girls in her tribe came of age around 13 years old and would often marry at age 13 or 14.
Over the next year, she helped save Smith and colonists from starvation by frequently bringing food and furs to the fort to trade with them. During her visits, she sought out Smith’s company. Her admiration for him was evident. On one occasion, her father sent her to negotiate the release of some Powhatan prisoners, and Smith said that he only agreed to release them for Pocahontas’s sake.
But she was also still a child at heart, during her visits to the fort, she enjoyed turning cartwheels with the boys: “she would follow and wheele some herself, naked as she was all the fort over” (naked because until Powhatan girls came of age, they wore very little clothing).
Smith may have viewed her as a child, but she left an indelible impression upon him. He found her striking and without peer: “a child of tenne yeares old, which not only for feature, countenance, and proportion much exceedeth any of the rest of his [Powhatan’s] people, but for wit, and spirit, the only Nonpariel of his Country.”
Pocahontas saved Smith’s life another time in 1609. A drought hit the region in the winter of 1608-1609, and relations between the English and her people worsened. Powhatan invited Smith and some of his men to his village to trade, but he snuck off with his family in middle of the night, planning to have Smith and his men killed. Risking her own life, Pocahontas traveled through the woods at night and snuck into Smith’s tent to warn him of the plan. It was the last time they saw each other that side of the Atlantic.
Powhatan moved his capital further away from the English settlement and didn’t allow Pocahontas to visit them anymore. Months later, Smith was seriously injured in a gun powder explosion and taken back to England for treatment. The colonists told Pocahontas that he was dead.
She grieved.
Pocahontas was a brave, young woman of character and unquenchable spirit who acted as a bridge between the Powhatan/Algonquians and the English. She treasured her relationship/friendship with John Smith.
(Check back next week to see learn about the man (men) she married and her reunion with Smith.)
Sources:
“Pocahontas: Her Life and Legend.” Historic Jamestown. National Park Service. https://www.nps.gov/jame/learn/historyculture/pocahontas-her-life-and-legend.htm#:~:text=After%20her%20capture%2C%20Pocahontas%20was,demands%20immediately%2C%20to%20open%20negotiations.
“Pocahontas.” Jamestown Rediscovery: Historic Jamestown. https://historicjamestowne.org/history/pocahontas/
(The drawing above is from the National Park Service.)
Join Sherry's
Writing Journey
Previous Posts
When We Can't, God Can
S.R. Shindelar
1/17/2025
A Civil War Christmas
Rev. John R. Paxton
12/18/2024
Maybe you
Erma Ullrey
9/20/2024
Interview with Historic Romance Author Susan Mathis
Sherry Shindelar
8/16/2024
I Was Born on the Prairie
Sherry Shindelar
8/12/2024
Waiting….
Jamie Ogle
2/9/2024
Quanah Wins His Bride
Sherry Shindelar
1/12/2024
Transforming Christmas
Sherry Shindelar
12/15/2023
Moravians: Missionaries to the Cherokee
Sarah Hanks
11/9/2023
A New Twist on Benjamin Franklin
Susan Page Davis
10/11/2023
Meet a Historical Romance Editor
Denise Weimer
9/15/2023
Making a Stand at King’s Mountain
Sherry Shindelar
8/11/2023
Female Spy Saves the Day
Sherry Shindelar
7/14/2023
Preparation Commune
Cathy Richmond
6/14/2023
The Teen Who Sculptured Lincoln
Sherry Shindelar
5/5/2023
Recipes from the Past: With Giveaway and Favor
Donna Schlachter
4/21/2023
Emeline Pigott: Confederate Spy
Sherry Shindelar
3/24/2023
First Great Awakening
Lynne Tagawa
3/10/2023
Stories that Haunt
Sherry Shindelar
2/24/2023
Valentine's Day 1983
Sherry Shindelar
2/10/2023
The Battle for Miss Nellie’s Heart
Sherry Shindelar
1/27/2023
Ukrainian Love Story
Sherry Shindelar
1/13/2023
Hannah
Sherry Shindelar
12/30/2022
The Bible Controversy of King James
Tamera Kraft
12/26/2022
Spymaster Extraordinaire
Sherry Shindelar
12/2/2022
Unshakeable
Sherry Shindelar
11/28/2022
God’s Tapestry: One Thread at a Time
Sherry Shindelar
11/4/2022
Ruth: Where Thou Goest, I Will Go (Part 1)
Sherry Shindelar
10/21/2022
Courtship in the Midst of War
Sherry Shindelar
9/30/2022
Identity Theft 597 BC
Sherry Shindelar
9/16/2022
Celebrating with Jamie Ogle
Sherry Shindelar
8/18/2022
Two Husbands for Pocahontas
Sherry Shindelar
8/5/2022
The Power of Stories
Sherry Shindelar
7/22/2022
Indian Princess and the Soldier: Love Story or Myth
Sherry Shindelar
7/15/2022
Tobacco Brides: Slavery, Indentureship, or Empowerment
Sherry Shindelar
7/1/2022
Jamestown: New Hope or Death Trap?
Sherry Shindelar
6/24/2022
Conquering Black Elk Peak and Staying Out of the Basement
Sherry Shindelar
6/3/2022
Encouraging Women and Shaping Culture with her Pen
Sherry Shindelar
5/20/2022
Operation Pied Piper
Linda Shenton Matchett
4/29/2022
A Crazy Summer of Romance
Kathy McKinsey
4/22/2022
When Prayers Aren’t Answered the Way You Expected
Sherry Shindelar
4/18/2022
Paper Bag Queen: A Female Edison
eMarie
4/1/2022
James Taylor: Capturing the World with a Pencil
Sherry Shindelar
3/18/2022
Undercover Girl Scout
Marie Sontag
3/3/2022
Forbidden Romance: From First Impression to Elopement
Sherry Shindelar
2/18/2022
What Can We Do with these Women
Sherry Shindelar
2/4/2022
Award-winning Historical Fiction Author Lori Benton Shares her Heart
Sherry Shindelar
1/21/2022
Bankrupt and Broke but Not Defeated
Sherry Shindelar
1/14/2022
From Shunned and Rowdy to Christmas as We Know It
Sherry Shindelar
12/17/2021
Where Thou Goest, I Will Go
Sherry Shindelar
12/3/2021
Edwardian Era: Most Photographed Woman
Jessica Sly
11/19/2021