Voices of the Past

Historical Romance Author

Two Husbands for Pocahontas
Friday, August 5, 2022 by Sherry Shindelar

Pocahontas was heartbroken over the loss of John Smith. She believed the colonists’ lie that the gallant captain, who had been the friend of her heart, died on the way back to England for medical treatment.

Before the deterioration in relations between the Powhatan/Algonquian people and the colonists, Pocahontas had been a frequent visitor to Jamestown.  After the reported death of Smith, she disappeared from their lives for four years. When she did eventually enter the fort walls again, it was against her will.

In 1610, a year after Smith’s departure, Pocahontas turned 14, the age of maturity in the Powhatan culture. She married a “private captain” named Kocoum. His title indicates he was a leader of warriors. However, he wasn’t a chief or a member of the ruling council, the usual choices for the daughter of a chief, especially the favorite daughter of the supreme chief of all of the Powhatan-allied Indians. Some suggest that this indicates that Pocahontas married for love, and it is believed that Kocoum could have been one of Powhatan’s bodyguards.

We don’t know what happened to Kocoum. But by 1613, Pocahontas was staying with the Patawomeck tribe. Historians suggest that this was Kocoum’s tribe and that he’d brought his wife here at the request of Powhatan to hide her from the English.   

Unfortunately, Captain Samuel Argall discovered Pocahontas’s location and devised a plan to kidnap her.  Relations between the Powhatan and the colonists had been poor for years, and Argall saw this as his opportunity to force Chief Powhatan to comply with their demands. He persuaded the sub-chief of the Patawomeck village, a tribe connected to the Powhatan, to trick Pocahontas. The sub-chief convinced her to accompany him and his wife onto Argall’s boat for dinner. The next morning the sub-chief and his wife left with a copper pot and some trinkets as a reward, and Pocahontas was locked in the gunner’s room and held prisoner.

Argall sent a note to Chief Powhatan demanding the release of English prisoners, the return of stolen weapons, and shipments of corn. He figured Powhatan would do whatever he asked in order to obtain the release of his daughter. However, in the end, Powhatan only sent part of the ransom.

Pocahontas never returned to her people. Argall brought his hostage to Jamestown but, eventually, moved her to Henrico, a new settlement near present-day Richmond. He placed her in the care of the Rev. Alexander Whitaker who began to teach her Christianity and English customs.

In July 1613, a few months after her capture, she met John Rolfe, the widower who engineered the planting of tobacco in Virginia. By 1614, Rolfe was torn between his desire to marry Pocahontas and his feeling that it would be a sin to marry a “strange woman,” “a non-Christian heathen.” He agonized for weeks about whether to propose.

His prayers were answered and his conflict was resolved when Pocahontas made the decision to follow Christ. She was baptized and changed her name to Rebecca, “the mother of two peoples.”  Rolfe married her “for the good of the plantation, the honor of our country, for the glory of God, and my own salvation…” As a romantic, I hope that love was in the mixture, too. Maybe, Rolfe didn’t feel it’d be dignified to say so.  And I’m definitely intrigued about his “for my own salvation” statement. Was he implying that he couldn’t contain his passion for her, and he needed to marry her before he sinned?

Big question: What happened to Kocoum? Historians believe he either died before Pocahontas was captured, or that he divorced her after her capture. Divorced was allowed in the Algonquian culture.

Her father approved of her marriage to Rolfe and sent family members to witness the wedding. The marriage of Pocahontas and John Rolfe instituted a new era of peace and good relations between their two peoples. And a baby followed in the coming year.

What about John Smith?

Pocahontas met him again when she and her husband traveled to England in 1616-1617. Smith wrote to Queen Anne about how vital Pocahontas was to the survival of Jamestown, but he didn’t come to visit Pocahontas until she’d been in England for several months. When they did meet again, at last, she was angry with him and overcome with emotion. She reprimanded him for how he’d treated her people and her father. And maybe deeper down was her hurt over him not returning to her.

It was their last meeting. Pocahontas died as she and her husband and young son prepared to set sail back to America.

The story of her courageous and kind heart lives on today: The girl who helped a colony survive. I really wish she had kept a journal so that we could know the journey of her heart.

Sources:

“Pocahontas: Her Life and Legend.” Historic Jamestown. National Park Service. https://www.nps.gov/jame/learn/historyculture/pocahontas-her-life-and-legend.htm#:~:text=After%20her%20capture%2C%20Pocahontas%20was,demands%20immediately%2C%20to%20open%20negotiations.

“Pocahontas.” Jamestown Rediscovery: Historic Jamestown. https://historicjamestowne.org/history/pocahontas/


Join Sherry's
Writing Journey



Previous Posts

When We Can't, God Can
S.R. Shindelar

1/17/2025

A Civil War Christmas
Rev. John R. Paxton

12/18/2024

Maybe you
Erma Ullrey

9/20/2024

Interview with Historic Romance Author Susan Mathis
Sherry Shindelar

8/16/2024

I Was Born on the Prairie
Sherry Shindelar

8/12/2024

Waiting….
Jamie Ogle

2/9/2024

Quanah Wins His Bride
Sherry Shindelar

1/12/2024

Transforming Christmas
Sherry Shindelar

12/15/2023

Moravians: Missionaries to the Cherokee
Sarah Hanks

11/9/2023

A New Twist on Benjamin Franklin
Susan Page Davis

10/11/2023

Meet a Historical Romance Editor
Denise Weimer

9/15/2023

Making a Stand at King’s Mountain
Sherry Shindelar

8/11/2023

Female Spy Saves the Day
Sherry Shindelar

7/14/2023

Preparation Commune
Cathy Richmond

6/14/2023

The Teen Who Sculptured Lincoln
Sherry Shindelar

5/5/2023

Recipes from the Past: With Giveaway and Favor
Donna Schlachter

4/21/2023

Emeline Pigott: Confederate Spy
Sherry Shindelar

3/24/2023

First Great Awakening
Lynne Tagawa

3/10/2023

Stories that Haunt
Sherry Shindelar

2/24/2023

Valentine's Day 1983
Sherry Shindelar

2/10/2023

The Battle for Miss Nellie’s Heart
Sherry Shindelar

1/27/2023

Ukrainian Love Story
Sherry Shindelar

1/13/2023

Hannah
Sherry Shindelar

12/30/2022

The Bible Controversy of King James
Tamera Kraft

12/26/2022

Spymaster Extraordinaire
Sherry Shindelar

12/2/2022

Unshakeable
Sherry Shindelar

11/28/2022

God’s Tapestry: One Thread at a Time
Sherry Shindelar

11/4/2022

Ruth: Where Thou Goest, I Will Go (Part 1)
Sherry Shindelar

10/21/2022

Courtship in the Midst of War
Sherry Shindelar

9/30/2022

Identity Theft 597 BC
Sherry Shindelar

9/16/2022

Celebrating with Jamie Ogle
Sherry Shindelar

8/18/2022

Two Husbands for Pocahontas
Sherry Shindelar

8/5/2022

The Power of Stories
Sherry Shindelar

7/22/2022

Indian Princess and the Soldier: Love Story or Myth
Sherry Shindelar

7/15/2022

Tobacco Brides: Slavery, Indentureship, or Empowerment
Sherry Shindelar

7/1/2022

Jamestown: New Hope or Death Trap?
Sherry Shindelar

6/24/2022

Conquering Black Elk Peak and Staying Out of the Basement
Sherry Shindelar

6/3/2022

Encouraging Women and Shaping Culture with her Pen
Sherry Shindelar

5/20/2022

Operation Pied Piper
Linda Shenton Matchett

4/29/2022

A Crazy Summer of Romance
Kathy McKinsey

4/22/2022

When Prayers Aren’t Answered the Way You Expected
Sherry Shindelar

4/18/2022

Paper Bag Queen: A Female Edison
eMarie

4/1/2022

James Taylor: Capturing the World with a Pencil
Sherry Shindelar

3/18/2022

Undercover Girl Scout
Marie Sontag

3/3/2022

Forbidden Romance: From First Impression to Elopement
Sherry Shindelar

2/18/2022

What Can We Do with these Women
Sherry Shindelar

2/4/2022

Award-winning Historical Fiction Author Lori Benton Shares her Heart
Sherry Shindelar

1/21/2022

Bankrupt and Broke but Not Defeated
Sherry Shindelar

1/14/2022

From Shunned and Rowdy to Christmas as We Know It
Sherry Shindelar

12/17/2021

Where Thou Goest, I Will Go
Sherry Shindelar

12/3/2021

Edwardian Era: Most Photographed Woman
Jessica Sly

11/19/2021


    Free Short Story